The Agentic Belonging Workshop: A Quasi-Experimental Evaluation of a Social Belonging Intervention in two English Universities

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5204/ssj.3667

Keywords:

Student belonging, Student agency, Impact evaluation, Agentic belonging

Abstract

Given its close links to student success, universities are heavily invested in how they can positively influence their students’ sense of belonging. One approach to this is through social belonging interventions, where universities attempt to develop student agency. This study takes a quasi-experimental approach by evaluating the impact of a newly developed agentic belonging workshop at two English universities. One hundred and one first-year undergraduate students attended either this belonging workshop (36), a control study-skills workshop (27), or they attended neither workshop (38). Findings show that the agentic workshop led to significantly higher self-reported scores in understanding of belonging amongst attendees compared to non-attendees. Whilst changes in students’ sense of belonging was not significantly different across workshop groups, belonging workshop attendees were significantly more likely to continue into the second year of study compared to both control groups. This study contributes promising findings for how social belonging interventions can be taken forward within the higher education context in the United Kingdom.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

David Gilani, Middlesex University

David Gilani works at Middlesex University as a staff governor and their Head of Student Engagement and Advocacy leading on their efforts to engage both current students and alumni. Having started his career as a students’ union officer, he is a strong proponent of the student voice and in 2012 he founded the Student Publication Association, which supports student journalists across the UK and Ireland. He believes strongly in universities working together to support student engagement efforts, and so leads AHEP’s Student Experience and Engagement Network. He has also recently completed his PhD at the University of York on the topic of student belonging.

Daniel McArthur, University of York

Lecturer in Education and member of the Centre for Research on Education and Social Justice at the University of York.

Liz Thomas, University of York

Liz Thomas is professor of higher education at the University of York, Visiting Professor at Aston Business School, Aston University and Visiting Professor at the Centre for Innovation in Higher Education at Anglia Ruskin.  Liz has been researching student diversity, experiences and equitable outcomes in higher education for over twenty-five years. She is committed to using research to improve policy, practice and equity, including the What works? Student retention and success programme (2008-2017) which focused on building student engagement and belonging.  In 2023-24 Liz worked with a number of institutions to develop a whole provider approach to student success. In 2024-25 she is working with the Technological Higher Education Association Ireland and higher education providers to explore whole provider and whole sector approaches to enabling commuter student engagement and success.

Downloads

Published

2024-12-17

How to Cite

Gilani, D., McArthur, D., & Thomas, L. (2024). The Agentic Belonging Workshop: A Quasi-Experimental Evaluation of a Social Belonging Intervention in two English Universities. Student Success, 16(1), 61–73. https://doi.org/10.5204/ssj.3667

Issue

Section

Articles